Отзывы на Mannochmore 2009 ElD (WB 84.11, 86 оценок) расходятся: часть текстов описывает лёгкий, фруктовый и элегантный профиль, часть — молодой, спиртовой и незрелый характер.
развернуть подробно
В текстовых отзывах (15 шт.) нет единого мнения. Несколько отзывов описывают виски как лёгкий и фруктовый: один из отзывов называет его «light and very fruity Speysider» с удачным выбором бочки; ещё один отзыв отмечает «wonderfully delicately put together», цитрусовые, мальт, цветы и мяту, «incredibly elegant»; другой отзыв — «much yellow fruit, vanilla, truly a summer dram»; один из отзывов — груши, клевер, маршмеллоу, ваниль. Ещё один отзыв описывает мягкий, сладкий нос с ванилью и мёдом, травянисто-цветочные ноты, дыню, абрикос и белый виноград, «elegant and layered», при этом вкус «spirity» с ощутимым алкоголем и сухим, почти бумажным телом.
Другие отзывы, критикуют незрелость и спиртовость. Другой отзыв прямо говорит, что 11 лет недостаточно для зрелости: остаётся лёгкая грушевая фруктовость, алкоголь присутствует в аромате, вкусе и финише, древесных нот нет, ваниль едва выражена. Один из отзывов называет виски «young and immature», нос — пыльный, алкогольный, с сеном, вкус — перечный и горячий, финиш короткий-средний с горчинкой. Ещё один отзыв описывает цвет как «white wine light» и предполагает не слишком активную бочку из-под бурбона. (слепая дегустация) отмечает мощную атаку, сухость и много дерева, но удивляется, что крепость «всего» 48%. Другой отзыв хвалит нос, но называет финиш плохим. Один из отзывов отмечает сильную спиртовость при сладости карамели и фуджа. Ещё один отзыв даёт лаконичные ноты мяты, ментола, жёлтых фруктов и «plain» вкус. Другой отзыв — «Very interesting nose, mouth somewhat disappointing». Несколько отзывов содержат лишь пометки о слепой дегустации и месте проведения.
собрано 15/27 текстовых отзывов · полный lossless-снимок WB
· 2026-09-13T00:43:30Z · источник evidence
glen efzeConnoisseur7809 jun 2021 8:28 pm
Another example of the light refill bourbon maturations that mature too short in barrels that are not particularly fresh. The 11 years were not enough to give the whisky a certain degree of maturity. It remains with typical pear-accentuated light fruitiness, the alcohol is 48% vol. present in the aroma and also the taste and finish are alcoholic with light fruit and light syrup. There are no wood notes, even the vanilla is barely pronounced. This whisky could not only be much younger than 11 years in terms of color. You don't need it.
HvdreeConnoisseur8519 jun 2021 4:03 pm
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
praisethepastaExpert Senior8521 apr 2022 10:27 am
A prime example of how refill barrels (my guess mostly 2nd and 3d fill) can work well with a distillery that produces a lighter style of whisky. Leave the talking to the spirit and just have the casks file off the rough edges so to speak.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
87
Things start of soft, sweet and clean. Classic refill bourbon casks with vanilla and honey notes, but then there’s this herbaceous note and things become really interesting from there on. It’s got this delicate soapy, lavender like touch to it, with hints of greenhouse flowers like geraniums. It evolves further when white and stone fruits emerge – melon, apricot and white grape, which make themselves comfortable as the nose finally settles down. Gentle, almost delicate even, pleasant, elegant and layered as well.
Вкус
85
the ABV makes a stand, quite abruptly at first. This is more ‘spirity’ in every sense of the word as it has both a clear prickly alcohol touch to it, yet also the flavour and character of the new make shine through. Again the fruity elements from melons, apricot and grapes, teaming up with those herbal/floral notes developing into a dense creamy, cheese-like note, ending with something reminiscent of old oak. This translates into the mouthfeel as well, as it’s medium full and dry – almost paper like, evolving into a dry and woody sensation.
Финиш
84
medium long, spicy and dry
WARciechExpert Senior8506 aug 2026 11:06 am
ffmdinoConnoisseur—29 jul 2022 2:53 pm
blind tasting the notes are hard to beat especially on the nose the finish is bad one can describe the malt as pleasing; but it's not a malt for me
-Blind tasting- I like it a lot, but I find it difficult to classify and classify it. But I'll try it anyway: a Scotch single malt from the ex-bourbon cask, because of its heavy attack on the tongue I'd guess 57-58%. Region could be Highlands, but somehow I got into a distillery that I can't get off of now. So I type Islay and: Bruichladdich. Due to the very dry start, one could conclude that it is old, but I don't trust the roast, especially given the finish, which is just about medium-long. So 8-10 years. (After resolution: unbelievable that he "only" has 48%.)
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
85
Appears light, airy and fresh at the beginning. Fresh red apples, blood orange, grapefruit. Freshly washed laundry drying on a line in the wind. Over time, spices such as thyme, rosemary and chervil appear, but also cinnamon and coriander, which give the nose a sweet and spicy touch. Some alcohol flashes through here and there, but that's not really disturbing.
Вкус
85
Enormously powerful acceleration, very dry and with a lot of wood. Sweetish-tart fruits that could also be found in the nose: blood orange and grapefruit. In addition, ginger biscuits, cinnamon rolls, a slight hint of herbs, lots of spices. Vanilla crescent and honey, fudge, toffee, malt. Towards the end there are maritime notes and it transports me to the beach of a Scottish island...
Финиш
84
Still of medium length and very dry, some dry wood, tart herbs and tart fruit.
Der_SchnappuliererExpert Senior7914 mar 2022 11:52 am
Blind probe
нос 80 · вкус 78 · финиш 78
HokkaidoUniExpert Senior8227 feb 2023 5:24 am
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
85
Poached pears and a bit of clove. Crème fresh. Marshmallow thickness. Charred apples. Cream soda. Vegetable oil. Brioche, a bit of brie. Oak as it opens. Melon and margarita Apple wine gums. Vanilla extract. A bit of bramble. With water - no real change.
Вкус
81
Malty, pears, some good body. Tweedy. Not much change with water.
Финиш
81
Bittersweet and vanilla
Cubey666Connoisseur8208 sep 2023 9:38 am
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
81
much yellow fruit, vanilla, truly a summer dram.
Вкус
83
sweet, honey, lychees, vanilla
Финиш
83
vanilla, sweet, sugar dram, taste like sunshine
Wolf68Connoisseur8525 jun 2021 7:59 pm
нос 86 · вкус 85 · финиш 84
JNuytsConnoisseur8731 jul 2025 2:03 pm
Glenrothes1973Connoisseur8604 jul 2021 9:34 pm
Light and very fruity Speysider. Great cask selection!
нос 87 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
HYTTTTTTExpert Junior8319 apr 2022 5:58 pm
WhiskeyMasterMember Senior7615 jan 2022 8:19 pm
нос 78 · вкус 77 · финиш 74
Monte GehroConnoisseur7824 mar 2022 10:19 pm
Notes from a blind tasting - Fassstark.de Taste Experiment 2022 Looks young and immature. I would not buy.
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
79
Brrr. Dusty, alcoholic, hay. At first it has almost nothing that I associate with pleasant whisky aromas. After a while: not so dusty anymore, plus some citrus and pear. Really needs time. Then it becomes reasonably pleasant; Nevertheless, it remains alcoholic and almost spritty.
Вкус
78
Slightly sweet, light vanilla, a little pear and sour citrus, peppery and hot on the tongue, without connecting it with oak spice. A little more pleasant and balanced with water.
Финиш
76
Short to medium, without anything new. Strong white pepper on the tongue, with a tendency towards bitterness in the finish.
SquinugieConnoisseur8525 aug 2022 8:16 pm
нос 85 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
Rosebank88Connoisseur8830 sep 2023 2:26 pm
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
88
Wonderfully delicately put together. Fine balsamic lemon tones, malt, grass, cut flowers, mint. With water: mint, jasmine, malt, lemon balm. Really good!
Вкус
89
Wonderful oily attack, huge citrus tones, oak, floral reflexes, slightly herbaceous and some white pepper. With water: fantastic citrus tones, malt, subtle notes of fully ripe early apples and Provence melon. Really very good and incredibly elegant
Финиш
87
Long, citrusy, oak, grass and floral notes
SirTobyExpert Senior8514 sep 2025 11:53 am
Color - light white wine
нос · вкус · финиш
Нос
84
fruity with notes of floury apples and slightly unripe pears, followed by vanilla and burnt caramel, slight bitterness from the wood
Вкус
87
Immediately quite sweet with caramel and fudge, yet very strong from the alcohol. Once the burn from the alcohol has passed, a pleasantly sweet warmth remains, with fruity, sour, sweet apples. I had an espresso in between - a fantastic combination with the whisky!
Финиш
84
warm, long and beautiful
pjarmoNewbie8116 dec 2021 8:13 pm
нос 80 · вкус 81 · финиш 81
Mark-EConnoisseur8528 sep 2021 9:51 pm
нос 84 · вкус 86 · финиш 85
sotongwong98Expert Senior8112 jan 2023 8:51 am
нос 81 · вкус 83 · финиш 80
NinofdramConnoisseur8303 sep 2023 2:20 pm
нос 83 · вкус 85 · финиш 82
GloinExpert Senior8414 mar 2022 11:36 am
Very interesting nose, mouth somewhat disappointing
fransoif@bdxExpert Senior8431 oct 2025 7:02 pm
Tasted at Sherry Butt, Paris, 10/23.
glen efzeConnoisseur7814 apr 2022 10:00 am
Mannochmore is another distillery that you hardly notice, although it produces huge amounts of alcohol. There are Mannochmores in the Flora & Fauna series and the occasional independent bottler. This is a white wine light bottling in Parcel No. 5 of The Single Malts of Scotland by Elixir Distillers. The color suggests a not too active bourbon barrel - or fear ... www.glen-efze.de
Оценки по участникам WB
эксперты 84.0среднее только по явному allowlist ролей; служебные роли не считаются экспертизой
снимок #2441 ·
статус complete · собран 2026-09-13T06:08:31+00:00 ·
сверено: строки сходятся с объявленным числом · показан более ранний доказанно полный снимок, новый #17033 (legacy_import) неполон
· ожидалось 86,
фактических строк 86, сохранено 86
экспертный allowlist: Expert Junior, Expert Senior, Specialist, Connoisseur.
Служебные роли (Administrator, Community Manager, Editor, Photo Moderator, Shoplink Moderator, Super Administrator) остаются ролью, но
экспертизой не объявляются. Авторское смещение не применяется:
author-bias correction not applied; view is raw observations.
показано 50 из 69 (экспертных наблюдений;
всего в снимке 86)
· страница 1 из 2 · за страницей ещё 19
Одно наблюдение = одна строка исходной таблицы;
повторные оценки одного автора сохраняются. «Дата неизвестна»
означает отсутствие даты в источнике, а не время сбора.
glen efze
Connoisseur
78
09 jun 2021 8:28 pm
Hvdree
praisethepasta
WARciech
ffmdino
JacobaEd
TomAndIngrid
Archer
Der_Schnappulierer
HokkaidoUni
Cubey666
Wolf68
JNuyts
Glenrothes1973
HYTTTTTT
Monte Gehro
Squinugie
Rosebank88
SirToby
pjarmo
Mark-E
sotongwong98
Ninofdram
Gloin
fransoif@bdx